Writing for HS, AM (Scalice, '07)
Response to Sin City Review
Last updated at 2007/07/16 07:07:50 PDT by scarrgo

I have never seen the movie but from the review it seems disgusting and R-rated. They way he described the movie made me not want to see it and I agree with his persuation review. It seems like he was upset with how they made it; violent and sexual with a weak plot. He also thought about it thoroughly and reasonable counter arguements that would hold up and provided evidence for them. THe arguements are all understandable and good in allowing the reader to pick a side for themselves.

Walsh uses a very strong word to describe the movie, porno-sadism. He thought that it combined sexual related stuff with murdering and violence. He thinks this is horrible and degrading but when looked closer at he sees the similarities in the real world with people murder each other. He wonders if it depicts real life. I would have to disagree with that but it doesn't there is not violence. WAlsh thought that the movie was bad and after reading his review I understand where he is coming from.

Powered by Io Community Manager